|
|
|
|
Central Banking In Islamic Framework
|
|
|
Introduction
|
|
|
The central bank has the sole authority to issue money (currency) and the responsibility to regulate the banking system in order to secure the value of money and realize the other objectives of monetary policy. Money serves as the medium of exchange and the commonly accepted means of payment, and as such as a measure of value. Excessive fluctuations in the value of money lead to economic distortions and causes social inequities. Inflation gives windfall gains to the rich and the business people but causes hardship to the fixed and low-income groups by eroding their purchasing power. Worse still, deflation often deprives the latter of their employment and means of livelihood. The phenomena of inflation and deflation are characteristic of the financial system based on the institution of interest, which is prohibited in Islam.
|
|
|
Objectives of monetary policy in Islam
|
|
Consistent
with the Islamic ideals of social justice, equity, fairness and balance,
there are three major objectives of monetary policy in an Islamic economy,
which discards interest. These objectives are:
- Stability
in the value of money;
- Economic
well-being with full employment and optimum rate of economic growth; and
- Distributive
justice.
For a
proper appreciation of the above-mentioned objectives of monetary policy
and how these may be realized, they are explained below.
Stability
in the Value of Money In an
Islamic economy it is almost mandatory on the central bank to preserve the
value of money. Thus the central bank should allow expansion of money
supply to the extent it is justified by a possible contribution to growth
in real balances. The stability in the value of money should be accorded
high priority because of the unequivocal stress of Islam on honesty and
fairness in all human dealings, and because of the negative impact of
inflation on socio-economic justice and general welfare. But, rather than
absolute, this objective would mean relative stability in the general
price level. Absolute price stability is neither feasible nor desirable as
it may conflict with the optimum growth and full employment objective of
the monetary policy.
Economic
Growth and Employment While
inflation is incompatible with the goals of an Islamic economy, prolonged
recession and unemployment that cause human sufferings are also
unacceptable. Monetary policy has, therefore, to aim at a high rate of
economic growth with full employment and utilization of productive
resources. However, maximization of economic growth per se and at
all costs is not the objective of monetary policy in an Islamic economy.
Material prosperity is to be attained within the framework of Islamic
values. It should not be attained through the production of essential and
morally - questionable goods and services. It should not lead to an
excessive and overly-rapid use of Allah-given resources at the expense of
future generations, and it should not be harmful to present or future
generations by degenerating the moral and physical environment.
Environmental degeneration with degradation and depletion of land, water
and forest resources and serious air and water pollution are already
matters of great concern around the world. Hence the concept of
“sustainable development", which means meeting the needs of the present
generation without compromising the needs of future generations. Economic
development and sound environmental management are complementary aspects
of the same agenda. Without adequate environmental protection, development
will be undermined; without development, environmental protection will
fail.
Distributive
Justice Monetary
policy should be used actively to promote the goal of distributive justice
and prevent concentration of wealth and economic power in an Islamic
economy. However, too much concern with distributive justice in
formulating and implementing monetary policy may adversely affect its
overall efficiency and effectiveness in attaining the other goals of
monetary policy. e.g. growth, employment and development. Reduction in
income inequalities and necessary redistribution should be an important
policy objective of an Islamic state and hence the domain, mainly, of its
fiscal policy. Monetary policy can contribute to this
objective.
|
|
|
Functions of the Central Bank
|
|
Pivot of
the Islamic banking System: The
central bank should be the pivot of the Islamic Banking System, because
only through its conscientious and creative efforts and eternal vigilance
can the Islamic money and banking system function properly and achieve its
objectives. It should be an autonomous government institution responsible
for the realization of the socio-economic goals of the Islamic economy in
the sphere of money and banking.
Issue of
Currency: Like all
central banks, the central bank in an Islamic economy should be
responsible for the issue of currency and, in coordination with the
government, for its internal and external stability. It should act as
banker to the government and the member banks. It should make arrangements
for clearance and settlement of checks and for transfers, and should act
as the lender of last resort. It should guide, supervise and regulate the
commercial banks, the non-bank and specialized financial institutions,
without unduly affecting their autonomy. Unlike the conventional central
bank, it should also bear the responsibility of preventing the
concentration of wealth and power through the financial institutions.
Stabilization
of the Value of Money:
Stabilization of the real value of money should be an important function
of the central bank in order to realize the healthy sustainable growth of
the Islamic economy and to ensure socio-economic justice. For this
purpose, it would have to keep a close watch on money supply, to ensure
that the growth in money is not out of step with that in real output. This
does not imply that the money supply is the only variable influencing
prices. All it implies is that the money supply matters, and that
without its proper regulation one of the important instruments for
realizing the economic goals of Islam will have been blunted.
Implementation
of Monetary Policy: The
central bank should be the primary institution responsible for
implementing the country's monetary policy. For this purpose, it
should use the instruments and methods that are not in conflict with the
teachings of the Islamic Shariah. Further, since the central bank
cannot realize the goal of monetary stability without cooperation from the
government, a harmonious fiscal - budgetary policy would be indispensable.
Promotion,
Regulation and Supervision: The
central bank will also have to play a positive role in the promotion,
regulation and supervision of all financial institutions with the
objective of helping them and making them healthy and strong. For this
purpose it may have to review all existing laws and amend or reconstitute
them in the light of Islamic teachings. The reformed banking legislation
should reflect the different needs of the Islamic financial system.
Ensure
health and Development of Public Interest: The
central bank should not confine its regulatory role merely to the
commercial banks. Its vigilance and assistance must envelop all other
financial institutions to ensure their health and development and to
safeguard the public interest. If some other government agencies are
responsible for promoting and regulating non-bank financial and auxiliary
institutions, then there should be proper coordination between the Central
bank and other regulatory authorities to bring on harmony in their
promotional and regulatory functions.
Lender of
the Last Resort: As
in conventional banking, the Islamic central bank would also have to act
as the lender of last resort to ensure sufficient liquidity and to sustain
the banks in case of liquidity or solvency crisis. Its ingenuity would be
reflected in the way it handled crisis situations without bailing out bank
management and yet safeguarding the interest of depositors and
equity-holders who are not a part of the management. Temporary
accommodation from the central bank provides the borrowing bank with a
brief respite and enables it to survive until remedial measures are
enforced and become effective. This is necessary for maintaining
confidence in the banking system.
Financial
Assistance by the Central Banks:
The central bank, to help any Islamic bank tide over its temporary
liquidity problem, may provide general accommodation in the form of
Mudaraba deposit on which the Islamic bank may pay profit at the
rate declared on such deposits.
The
central bank may also provide refinance to Islamic banks against finance
provided by them for purposes, projects or sectors specified by the
central bank. Such refinance may be provided under Mudaraba,
Musharaka or any other Islamic mode of finance.
Current
Account and Clearing House Facility:
Islamic
banks may be allowed to maintain current accounts with the central bank
and to participate in the bank's clearing house operations. If the current
account is occasionally overdrawn, the central bank may provide this
facility without any charge. Alternatively, such facility may be extended
on the basis of sharing of the profits of the bank.
Regulation
and Supervision of Islamic Banks:
Islamic
banks may be subjected to regulations and controls by the Central bank in
respect of (a) permission to establish banks and to open new
branches; (b) minimum share capital; (c) the terms
governing the constitution of Boards of Directors and appointment of Chief
Executives and auditors; (d) tariffs for banking services; (e)
measures regulating foreign exchange transactions; (f) submission of
periodical statements and operational data to the central bank
and (g) Compliance with the working hours.
Inspection
of Islamic Banks:
Islamic
banks may be subjected to periodic inspection by the central bank to
ensure their operational soundness. The central bank personnel may be
adequately trained in Shariah-based operations of Islamic Banks.
Detailed guidelines for inspection of the Islamic banks should be prepared
and set by the central bank, as it should carry out research and training
of personnel.
Bank
supervision and inspection would be more important in an Islamic system.
Unlike the examination of conventional banks, it may be necessary to
ensure that, in addition to proper documentation, the projects financed
dare sound. To examine all projects financed by the banks would be
difficult. It should, however, be possible to examine a random sample of
projects financed to ensure that banks do not indulge in financing
speculative or unduly risky ventures. Supervision should not be concerned
solely with individual banks. It should acquire an operational importance
and should aim at promoting the efficiency and stability of the whole
financial system, by means of action directed towards both the system
itself and individual components, without interfering in moral operational
decisions. Moreover, supervision presupposes adequate disclosure and
accurate information, and proper auditing. The central bank should play an
important role in determining the requirements for this purpose. It should
try to strengthen internal controls and issue policy guidelines, and
monitor the quality of assets and operations. It should reform the
concepts and procedures of auditing to ensure soundness and
honesty.
|
|
|
Sources of monetary expansion
|
|
To ensure
that growth of money supply is adequate and not excessive, it would be
necessary and important to monitor carefully all three of the major
sources of monetary expansion. The two domestic
sources are: i) Financing of government fiscal/budgetary
deficits by borrowing from the Central bank; and ii) Expansion of
deposits through commercial bank credit creation. The third source
of monetary growth is external and is monetization of a balance of
payments surplus.
i)
Fiscal Deficits - Fiscal
deficits can be, and have been, an important source of excessive monetary
expansion. Attempts by the government to extract real resources at a
faster rate than is sustainable at a stable price level could lead to
continually rising fiscal deficits and accelerated increases in money
supply, thus contributing to an inflationary spiral. This has tended to
shift a disproportionate burden of the fight against inflation onto the
monetary policy. According to one important study, "the greater the
dependence of the public sector on the banking system, the harder it is
for the central bank to pursue a consistent monetary policy". Hence
for the monetary policy to be effective, there must be coordination
between monetary and fiscal policies for the realization of national
goals. This under scores the need for a realistic and non-inflationary
fiscal policy in a Muslim country. This does not necessarily rule out
fiscal deficits but imposes the constraint that deficits be allowed only
to the extent necessary to achieve sustainable long-run growth and
broad-based well-being within the framework of stable prices.
The need
to eliminate unproductive and wasteful spending is a religious imperative
for all Muslims. It is particularly important for governments because they
use resources provided by the people as a trust, and using these
wastefully or unproductively is a breach of this trust. The limited
resources must be used efficiently and effectively with the acute
consciousness of accountability to Allah. It requires a careful review of
the entire expenditure program in the light of Islamic teachings.
After all
the wasteful and unnecessary spending has been eliminated, the balance of
government spending may be divided into three parts:
1.
normal
recurring expenditures
2.
project
expenditures
3.
emergency
expenditures
All
normal, recurring government expenditures, including outlays on projects
not amenable to profit-and-loss sharing arrangements, must be financed by
tax revenues. The non-availability of debt financing for such purposes
should prove to be a hidden blessing and help introduce the needed
discipline in government spending. The government may undertake projects,
which are amenable to equity financing, where this is necessary in the
public interest, but the financing should be obtained by selling shares to
financial institutions and the public. A commercially oriented pricing
system should be adopted without a general subsidy. All subsidies
needed for the poor and lower middle class families should be arranged
from Zakat revenues, donations or Qard Hasan. Equity
financing and commercial pricing should help eliminate some of the
unnecessary and unproductive or prestigious projects that governments
sometimes undertake to satisfy vested interests. Emergency expenses or
unavoidable deficits, which cannot be financed by either of the two ways
may be financed by borrowing from the banking system within a
non-inflationary framework and to a limited extent.
ii)
Commercial Bank Credit Creation:
Commercial bank deposits constitute a significant part of money
supply. These deposits may, for the sake of analysis, be divided
into two parts
'primary
deposits', which provide the banking system with the base money
(cash-in-tills plus deposits with the central bank); and
'derivative
deposits' which, in a proportional reserve system, represent money created
by commercial banks in the process of credit expansion and constitute a
major source of monetary expansion.
Since
derivative deposits lead to an increase in money supply in the same manner
as currency issued by the government or the central bank, and since this
expansion, just like government deficits, has the potential of being
inflationary in the absence of an offsetting growth in output, the
expansion in derivative deposits must be regulated if the desired monetary
growth is to be achieved. This could be accomplished by regulating the
availability of base money to the commercial banks.
iii)
Balance of Payments Surplus: Only a few Muslim countries
have enjoyed a balance of payments surplus in recent years, while
most of them have experienced deficits. In the few that did have a
surplus, the surplus did not originate in the private sector and did not
lead to an automatic expansion in money supply. It did so only to the
extent government monetised the surplus by spending it domestically and
the private sector balance of payments deficit did not offset this
adequately. In the Muslim countries that have a balance of payment
deficit, it is unhealthy monetary expansion along with public and private
sector conspicuous consumption that generate the balance of payments
disequilibrium through current account deficits and underground capital
outflows. These cannot be removed without socio-economic reform at a
deeper level and healthy monetary and fiscal policies in the light of
Islamic teachings.
|
|
|
Instruments of monetary policy
|
|
To realize
the objectives of monetary policy in an Islamic framework, the central
bank in an Islamic economy may use the following instruments, jointly or
separately, for regulation of money and credit:
- Target
Growth in Money Supply: The
central bank should determine annually the growth desired in the money
supply (M) in the light of national economic goals, including the
desired but sustainable rate of economic growth and the stability in the
value of money. This target growth in M should be reviewed quarterly, or
as often as necessary, in the light of the performance of the economy
and the trend of important variables. However, the targets should not be
changed frequently but only when justified to accommodate economic
shocks, both domestic and external.
- Statutory
Reserve Requirements:
Statutory Reserve requirements against the commercial banks' deposit
liabilities usually consist of two parts: (a) Compulsory Cash Reserve
Ratio (CRR), and (b) Liquidity Ratio (LR). Commercial banks may be
required to deposit with the central bank in cash as CRR a certain
proportion, say 5-10 percent, of their total deposits from the public.
In addition, the banks may be required to keep with themselves shortly
maturing liquid assets, say 10-15 percent, against their deposits. These
reserves serve the twin purpose of security and control of the banks'
capacity to create credit. Reserve requirements against demand deposits
may be higher, while requirements against savings and Term
(Mudaraba) deposits may be lower because of their equity nature,
meant for investment by the banks and not supposed to be withdrawn
frequently. The statutory reserve requirements may be varied by the
central bank according to the dictates of monetary policy.
- Credit
Ceilings:
It may
be desirable to fix ceilings on commercial bank credit to ensure that
total credit creation is consistent with monetary targets. Ins the
allocation of this ceiling among individual commercial banks,
appropriate care should be taken to ensure that it does not harm healthy
competition among banks.
- Allocation
of Credit:
Since
bank credit comes out of funds belonging to the public, it should be so
allocated that it helps to realize general social welfare. The criteria
for its allocation, as for other Allah given resources, should be,
first, the realization of the goals of the Islamic society, and, second,
the maximization of private profit. This could be attained by ensuring
that (a) credit allocation leads to an optimum production and
distribution of goods and services needed by the majority of the
society, and (b) the benefit of credit goes to an optimum number of
businesses in society.
- Selective
Credit Control:
In addition to the general qualitative controls, the central bank may
use qualitative or selective credit controls to ensure the flow of
credit to the desired direction, purpose and extent. For example,
central bank Mudaraba financing may not be made available
except for specific purposes. The Central bank may also accept a
relatively lower profit-sharing ratio, if considered necessary, for
realizing the objective of distributing commercial bank financing to an
optimum number of businesses for production of the goods and services,
which are most needed.
- Moral
Suasion: Moral
suasion or persuasion should acquire an important place in Islamic
central banking. The central bank through its personal contracts,
consultations and meetings with the banks could keep itself abreast of
the strengths and problems of banks and suggest to them measures to
overcome difficulties and achieve the desired goals.
- Other
Instruments: For
proper functioning of the monetary and credit system and to secure its
objectives and mandate the Islamic central bank may also use the
following instruments to replace the Bank Rate or Discount Rate and
control through regulation of interest rates:
- Fixing
a minimum and/ or maximum ratio of profit for Islamic banks in their
joint venture and Mudaraba activities. These ratios may
vary for different fields of activity.
- Designation
of various fields for investment and partnership within the framework
of the approved economic policies, and the fixing of a minimum
prospective rate of profit for the various investment and partnership
projects. The minimum prospective rate of profit may vary with respect
to different branches of activity.
- Fixing
a minimum and maximum margin of profit, as a proportion to the cost
price of the goods transacted, for banks in installment and hire
purchase transactions.
- Determination
of types and the minimum and maximum accounts of commissions for
banking services.
- Determination
of the types, amounts, minimum and maximum bonuses, and the
establishment of guidelines for advertisements by banks.
- Determination
of the minimum and maximum ratio in joint venture, Mudaraba
investment, hire purchase, installment transactions, buying or selling
on credit, forward deals with respect to various fields of activity;
and also fixing the maximum facility that can be granted to each
customer.
|
|
|
|
|
|